Skip to main content
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 2/1.
Mrs. Moo's Corner
  • Menu
  • Order Online
  • Gift Card
  • Catering
  • Join Our Team
  • Contact Us
  • Spider Hall Farm
Various flavors of icecream on waffle cone

Ice Cream Menu

Become a VIPReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Ice Cream Menu

Hand Scooped Ice Cream

Flavors vary on a daily basis. Please check our Facebook page for a recent update.

Kids Hand Scooped Ice Cream
12 reviews
$4

Kids Hand Scooped Ice Cream

110047
 
Single Hand Scooped Ice Cream
15 reviews
$5

Single Hand Scooped Ice Cream

101027
 
Double Hand Scooped Ice Cream
8 reviews
$6

Double Hand Scooped Ice Cream

81007
 
Take Home Container
11 reviews
110038

Take Home Container

Quart $101/2 Gallon $17
 
Strawberry Shortcake Cookie Sandwich
$8

Strawberry Shortcake Cookie Sandwich

00000

Strawberry Shortcake (butter cookie, by Crumb Snatchers, strawberry ice cream, rolled in golden oreos)

 
Chocolate Shortcake Cookie Sandwich
1 review
$8

Chocolate Shortcake Cookie Sandwich

10001

Chocolate Shortcake ( butter cookie, by Crumb Snatchers, chocoholic ice cream, rolled in oreos)

 
Coconut Keylime Cookie Sandwich
$8

Coconut Keylime Cookie Sandwich

00000

Toasted coconut, white chocolate keylime cookies (made by Crumb Snatchers), coconut ice cream, rolled in graham cracker crumbs

 
Brownie Sandwich
$8

Brownie Sandwich

00000

Choose your brownie and your ice cream for a delicious sandwich

 

Soft Serve Ice Cream

Available in vanilla, cotton candy or twist flavors.

Soft Serve Ice Cream
6 reviews
80026

Soft Serve Ice Cream

Available in vanilla, cotton candy or twist flavors.

Small $4Large $5
 
Sprinkle Madness
2 reviews
70052

Sprinkle Madness

Your choice of soft serve layered with rainbow sprinkles!

Small 12 oz $8Large 20 oz $10
 

Classic Treats

Classic Milkshake
9 reviews
1410112

Classic Milkshake

Your choice of hand-scooped ice cream blended with milk, and topped with whipped cream and a cherry

Small (12 oz) $7Large (20 oz) $9
 
Malt
4 reviews
40013

Malt

Your choice of hand-scooped ice cream blended with malt, and topped with whipped cream and a cherry

Small (12 oz) $7Large (20 oz) $9
 

Floats

Holly Jolly Float
1 review
00000

Holly Jolly Float

Vanilla ice cream with cranberry and orange juice topped with whipped cream

Small 12oz $8Large 20oz $10
 
Gumdrop Float
1 review
10010

Gumdrop Float

Red Raspberry Sorbet with 7up and garnished with gumdrops (dairy free)
Lemon Lime sherbet with 7up and garnished with gumdrops
Lemon sorbet with 7up and garnished with gumdrops (dairy free)

Small 12oz $8Large 20oz $10
 
Hot Chocolate Float
1 review
10001

Hot Chocolate Float

Hot Chocolate Float
Made with vanilla ice cream, or if you want to get adventurous, cookies and cream ice cream, marshmallow drizzle, hot chocolate, topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle

Small (12oz) $8Large (20oz) $10
 
Apple Cider Float
2 reviews
10001

Apple Cider Float

Apple Cider Float
Made with salted caramel ice cream, caramel drizzle, fresh local apple cider, topped with whipped cream and caramel drizzle

Small (12oz) $8Large (20oz) $10
 

Specialty Milkshakes

Banana Split Specialty Milkshake
4 reviews
20002

Banana Split Specialty Milkshake

Chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry ice cream combined with a banana into a shake, with chocolate and strawberry drizzle

Small (12 oz) $8Large (20 oz) $10
 
20002

Banana Pudding Specialty Milkshake

Vanilla shake with bananas and our banana pudding mix

Small (12 oz) $8Large (20 oz) $10
 
Blueberry Pie Specialty Milkshake
1 review
10001

Blueberry Pie Specialty Milkshake

Vanilla shake with blueberries and graham crackers

Small (12 oz) $8Large (20 oz) $10
 
CHAI TEA MILKSHAKE
2 reviews
30003

CHAI TEA MILKSHAKE

Vanilla ice cream blended with chai tea, topped with whipped cream and a sprinkle of nutmeg 🍁

Small (12 oz) $8Large (20 oz) $10
 
20002

Cinnamon Toast Crunch Specialty Milkshake

Vanilla shake with cinnamon toast crunch

Small (12 oz) $8Large (20 oz) $10
 
Funfetti Cake Batter Specialty Milkshake
3 reviews
60024

Funfetti Cake Batter Specialty Milkshake

Vanilla shake with cake mix and rainbow sprinkles

Small (12 oz) $8Large (20 oz) $10
 
Fruity Pebbles Specialty Milkshake
6 reviews
50032

Fruity Pebbles Specialty Milkshake

Vanilla shake with fruity pebbles

Small (12 oz) $8Large (20 oz) $10
 
Mocha Cookie Crumble Specialty Milkshake
4 reviews
70007

Mocha Cookie Crumble Specialty Milkshake

Coffee shake with oreos and a chocolate drizzle

Small (12 oz) $8Large (20 oz) $10
 
Peanut Butter Brownie Specialty Milkshake
5 reviews
50014

Peanut Butter Brownie Specialty Milkshake

Peanut butter shake with brownies

Small (12 oz) $8Large (20 oz) $10
 
Reese's Pieces Specialty Milkshake
2 reviews
100037

Reese's Pieces Specialty Milkshake

Vanilla shake with reeses pieces

Small (12 oz) $8Large (20 oz) $10
 
Red Velvet Specialty Milkshake
3 reviews
30012

Red Velvet Specialty Milkshake

Vanilla shake with our red velvet mix

Small (12 oz) $8Large (20 oz) $10
 
S'mores Specialty Milkshake
2 reviews
20002

S'mores Specialty Milkshake

Vanilla shake with graham crackers, put in a cup with a marshmallow fluff bottom and chocolate drizzle

Small (12 oz) $8Large (20 oz) $10
 
Eggnog Milkshake
1 review
10010

Eggnog Milkshake

Eggnog Milkshake, topped with whipped cream and nutmeg

Small 12oz $8Large 20oz $10
 

Extreme Milkshakes

All of our extreme milkshakes come topped with a cake or pie slice specific to their flavor and whipped cream! 
Extreme milkshakes will be packaged to-go, with the cake or pie slice served in a to-go box. Please leave us a note if you would like it to be packaged as it is shown in the photos, thank you!

Apple Pie Extreme Milkshake
7 reviews
81016

Apple Pie Extreme Milkshake

Vanilla shake with apple pie filling and gram crackers. In a cup with apple pie filling at the bottom, drizzled with caramel sauce, a vanilla frosting and graham cracker rim, and topped with whipped cream and a slice of our apple pie

Small (12 oz) $11Large (20 oz) $14
 
Birthday Cake Extreme Milkshake
7 reviews
70016

Birthday Cake Extreme Milkshake

Vanilla shake with rainbow sprinkles and cake mix. In a cup with a vanilla frosting and rainbow sprinkle rim, and topped with whipped cream and cupcakes (one cupcake for a 12 oz, and two cupcakes for a 20 oz)

Small (12 oz) $11Large (20 oz) $14
 
Cookie Monster Extreme Milkshake
4 reviews
60015

Cookie Monster Extreme Milkshake

Cookie craver shake, in a cup with a blue vanilla frosting and cookie crisp rim, topped with whipped cream, two oreos, and a mini cookie sandwich

Small (12 oz) $11Large (20 oz) $14
 
The "ELVIS" Extreme Milkshake
3 reviews
40004

The "ELVIS" Extreme Milkshake

Peanut butter shake with bananas mixed in, put in a cup with marshmallow fluff on the bottom, a peanut butter and marshmallow rim, and topped with whipped cream and a slice a peanut butter pie

Small (12 oz) $11Large (20 oz) $14
 
Hot Fudge Sundae Extreme Milkshake
7 reviews
1200210

Hot Fudge Sundae Extreme Milkshake

Vanilla shake layered with hot fudge, in a cup with a rim of vanilla frosting and chocolate sprinkles, and topped with whipped cream, a cherry, and a slice of our chocolate spoon cake

Small (12 oz) $11Large (20 oz) $14
 
Oreo Extreme Milkshake
15 reviews
111019

Oreo Extreme Milkshake

Cookies and cream shake, in a cup with a chocolate drizzle, a rim of vanilla frosting and oreo dirt, and topped with whipped cream and a slice of our oreo pie

Small (12 oz) $11Large (20 oz) $14
 
Peanut Butter Brownie Extreme Milkshake
23 reviews
1400311

Peanut Butter Brownie Extreme Milkshake

Vanilla shake with peanut butter and brownie mixed in, put in a cup with a rim of chocolate frosting and reeses cups, and topped with whipped cream and a brownie

Small (12 oz) $11Large (20 oz) $14
 
Red Raspberry Cheesecake Extreme Milkshake
2 reviews
30003

Red Raspberry Cheesecake Extreme Milkshake

Red raspberry shake with a slice of cheesecake mixed in, put in a cup with a rim of vanilla frosting and graham crackers, and topped with whipped cream and a slice of our cheesecake!

Small (12 oz) $11Large (20 oz) $14
 
Red Velvet Extreme Milkshake
5 reviews
70016

Red Velvet Extreme Milkshake

Vanilla shake with our red velvet mix, in a cup with vanilla frosting in the bottom, a rim of vanilla frosting and oreo dirt, and topped with whipped cream and a slice of our red velvet cheesecake!

Small (12 oz) $11Large (20 oz) $14
 
German Chocolate Extreme Milkshake
6 reviews
30021

German Chocolate Extreme Milkshake

Coconut and butter pecan ice cream mixed with chocolate milk, chocolate mousse and caramel drizzle in the cup. The rim is chocolate frosting and coconut flakes. Topped with a slice of German Chocolate Cake and whipped cream

Small 12oz $11Large 20 oz $14
 
Creme Brulee Extreme:
30012

Creme Brulee Extreme:

Salted caramel ice cream with a butterscotch sauce mixed in, caramel drizzle, the rim is vanilla frosting and golden oreos, topped with a creme brulee cheesecake and whipped cream

Small (12oz) $11Large (20oz) $14
 
Sugar Cookie Extreme Milkshake
3 reviews
30021

Sugar Cookie Extreme Milkshake

Sugar cookie Milkshake, the rim is vanilla frosting and Christmas sprinkles, topped with a sugar cookie and a Little Debbie Christmas Tree, whipped cream

Small 12oz $11Large 20oz $14
 
Blueberry Cheesecake Extreme Milkshake
2 reviews
10001

Blueberry Cheesecake Extreme Milkshake

Blueberry cheesecake ice cream, a blueberry sauce drizzle, the rim is vanilla frosting and Graham cracker crumbs, topped with a slice of blueberry cobbler cheesecake, and whipped cream

Small 12oz $11Large 20oz $14
 
Gingerbread Extreme Milkshake
10001

Gingerbread Extreme Milkshake

Gingerbread milkshake, rim is vanilla frosting with ginger snap cookies, topped with Cake by Amanda's Gingerbread cookie, mini candy canes, whipped cream and sprinkles

Small 12oz $11Large 20oz $14
 
Butterfinger Extreme Milkshake
1 review
10001

Butterfinger Extreme Milkshake

Butterfinger ice cream, peanut butter drizzle in the cup, the rim is vanilla frosting and crushed Butterfinger, topped with a Butterfinger brownie (made by Crumb Snatchers) and whipped cream

Small (12 oz) $11Large (20 oz) $14
 
Melted Snowman Extreme Milkshake
00000

Melted Snowman Extreme Milkshake

Cookies and cream ice cream, marshmallow drizzle, rim is vanilla frosting and oreo dust, topped with a melted snowman cupcake made by Crumb Snatchers, and whipped cream

Small 12oz $11Large 20oz $14
 

Sundaes

$4

JR Build Your Own Sundae

70016

Up to 3 small hand scooped flavors of your choice, 1 topping of your choice, whipped cream, and a cherry.

 
Build Your Own Sundae
14 reviews
$8

Build Your Own Sundae

90036

Up to 3 large hand scooped flavors of your choice, 2 toppings of your choice, whipped cream, and a cherry.

 
Cookie Master Sundae
5 reviews
$8

Cookie Master Sundae

120048

1 scoop of cookie dough, 1 scoop of cookies n cream, and 1 scoop of cookie craver, with crushed chips ahoy, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry.

 
Peanut Butter Delight Sundae
5 reviews
$8

Peanut Butter Delight Sundae

60006

2 scoops of vanilla, and 1 scoop peanut butter, with hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, chopped peanuts, whipped cream, and a cherry.

 
Brownie Sundae
13 reviews
$8

Brownie Sundae

1400410

A brownie, topped with 3 scoops of your choice of hand-scooped ice cream, chocolate sauce, whipped cream, and a cherry.

 
Classic Banana Split
2 reviews
$9

Classic Banana Split

51004

Vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream, pineapple, strawberry sauce and chocolate sauce, chopped peanut, whipped cream, and three cherries.

 
Our Banana Split
5 reviews
$9

Our Banana Split

40013

Banana, 1 scoop chocolate, 1 scoop vanilla, and 1 scoop strawberry, chocolate sauce, strawberry sauce, rainbow sprinkles, whipped cream, and cherries

 
Chocolate Banana Split
2 reviews
$9

Chocolate Banana Split

30003

Chocoholic, Mississippi Mud, and Triple Chocolate ice cream, chocolate sauce, chocolate sprinkles, whipped cream and three cherries.

 
Peanut Butter Banana Split
7 reviews
$9

Peanut Butter Banana Split

60015

Banana, 1 scoop peanut butter, 1 scoop vanilla, and 1 scoop strawberry, peanut butter sauce, strawberry sauce, crushed peanuts, whipped cream, and cherries.

 
Lava Cake Sundae
$8

Lava Cake Sundae

20002

Warm Lava Cake with vanilla ice cream, chocolate drizzle, whipped cream and a cherry

 

Extreme Sundaes

Apple Pie Extreme Sundae
2 reviews
$12

Apple Pie Extreme Sundae

10001

Apple pie extreme sundae: 
Vanilla ice cream, salted caramel ice cream, and apple pie ice cream, caramel drizzle, slice of apple pie, slice of caramel apple roll

 
Black Forest Extreme Sundae
$12

Black Forest Extreme Sundae

00000

Black Forest extreme sundae: 
Black raspberry truffle ice cream, chocolate drizzle, raspberry drizzle, a slice of black Forest mousse bar, and a slice of brownie, whipped cream, and a cherry

 
Pecan Extreme Sundae
$12

Pecan Extreme Sundae

00000

Pecan extreme sundae:
Butter pecan ice cream, caramel drizzle, chocolate drizzle, slice of pecan pie, slice of pecan chocolate bar, whipped cream, and candied pecans

 
Cookie Lover's extreme Sundae
1 review
$12

Cookie Lover's extreme Sundae

30012

Chocolate drizzle, Cookies and Cream, cookie Dough, cookie craver ice cream 
Crushed oreos, oreo brownie, sliced diagonal
small chocolate chip cookie, brookie brownie, whipped cream and chocolate drizzle

 
Smore's Extreme Sundae
$12

Smore's Extreme Sundae

00000

Marshmallow drizzle, Mississippi Mud ice cream, sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs, smore brownie, smore smith island bite
whipped cream, chocolate drizzle

 

Moo-freshers

All of our Moo-freshers are made with our sorbets and are dairy free!

We are currently out of our raspberry sorbet and are unable to make any of our raspberry refreshers

Strawberry Lemonade Moo-Fresher
1 review
20011

Strawberry Lemonade Moo-Fresher

Lemon Sorbet with a strawberry drizzle!

Small (12 oz) $7Large (20 oz) $9
 
Red Rasperry Lemonade Moo-Fresher
00000

Red Rasperry Lemonade Moo-Fresher

Red raspberry sorbet and lemon sorbet!

Small (12 oz) $7Large (20 oz) $9
 

Sundae Kits

Personal Sundae Kit
1 review
$9.99

Personal Sundae Kit

10010

Choose from a Brownie, Lava Cake, Apple Pie Slice 
Double cup of ice cream
Sauce, whipped cream

 
Made with by Popmenu
Mrs. Moo's Corner
Website Accessibility Assistance
Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window